Sephora Ratings and Reviews

Eyeliner Reviews

Smoothing Eyeliner Pencil
Overall Rating: 5 of 5
"Glides on perfectly. It is versatile - you can draw a clean, sleek line or smudge it with the sponge tip. It is long-lasting. I actually have to remove it with make-up remover."...(read full reviews)
Liquid Liner
Overall Rating: 4.929 of 5
"This is my alltime favorite eyeliner. Goes on flawlessly each time whether you're in a hurry or not because it just glides on. I absolutely love the brush!"...(read full reviews)
WISH For The Perfect Pencils ($80 Value)
Overall Rating: 4.846 of 5
"GREAT COLORS BUT I FOUND THAT THEY ARE NOT TOTALLY LONG WEARING. MY EYES TEAR ALOT, SO THAT'S WHERE I HAVE THE PROBLEM."...(read full reviews)
Painting Liner Eye Liner
Overall Rating: 4.8 of 5
"After years of using many, many brands of eye liner I've finally found the one that works! This eye liner is easy to apply, easy to work with and long lasting. I highly recommend it."...(read full reviews)
Front of the Line PRO
Overall Rating: 4.704 of 5
"I love this eyeliner. I have been wanting to try something besides an eyeliner pencil because they tend to tug at my skin, which I hate. This make smooth lines and you can easily make them thin or"...(read full reviews)
The Makeup Eyeliner Pencil Duo
Overall Rating: 4.667 of 5
"love the double sided eyeliner in moonscape...just the right amount so that I can buy a fresh eyeliner more often than if I bought 2 individual eyeliners. A quick simple eye makeup routine for those"...(read full reviews)
Tattoo Liner
Overall Rating: 4.652 of 5
"This is a good liner. It is easy to use, the color comes out solid so you don't have to go over it again. It does still smudge a little bit, but I would say it has been the most waterproof liquid"...(read full reviews)
Sealing Gel
Overall Rating: 4.6 of 5
"This product I recommend to all of you beauty goddesses, easy to use small you can travel with and you can be creative ."...(read full reviews)
The Makeup Accentuating Cream Eyeliner
Overall Rating: 4.583 of 5
"i recently ordered my second one. i bought the one in black. its the blackest black you'll ever find. i remember shiseido was the first......if not, then it was one of the first that came out with a"...(read full reviews)
Starry-Eyed Liquid Eyeliner
Overall Rating: 4.583 of 5
"So Sparkly! Easy liner with exactly the right amount of sparkle to start, apply more if needed. No cakes or flakes, stays put!"...(read full reviews)
ARTLINER - Precision Point EyeLiner
Overall Rating: 4.573 of 5
"i was looking for a black liquid liner for halloween that i could also use for everyday use. this liner from lancome is effortless to use, goes on easy, and is one of the best to create those gorgeous"...(read full reviews)
Brush-On Cream Liner
Overall Rating: 4.569 of 5
"This cream eyeliner is awesome, and so much cheaper than many others! It doesn't come with a great brush, but thats okay b/c I already had one. Its very easy to apply and to blend."...(read full reviews)
24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
Overall Rating: 4.566 of 5
"I haven't worn eye liner in years. I bought this in taupe and love it. Now I wear it every day. It definitely stays put and it makes my eyes look bigger."...(read full reviews)
Babe Cakes
Overall Rating: 4.551 of 5
"I thoroughly enjoy the "Babe Cakes" eyeliner. It is easy to use and looks great on. My advice is to have a brush that is typically used with a wet eyeliner and practice with a dry liner or eye shadow."...(read full reviews)
Eye Pencil
Overall Rating: 4.526 of 5
"This is the best black pencil liner I've owned so far! I can't wait to try the other colors. :)"...(read full reviews)
Foiled Liners
Overall Rating: 4.518 of 5
"Loved the liner!! Great stuff makes eyes pop and stays put, BUT you can't sharpen this liner and the pencil looks long but doesn't last long. So it is expensive for the amount you can actually use."...(read full reviews)
Eye Liner
Overall Rating: 4.5 of 5
"this is the only liner that isn't smuding as the day goes on. my eyelids must be oily. i dip my brush in water and mix in liner to make a paste b/f applying. happiest i've been in a long time."...(read full reviews)
The Makeup Eyeliner Pencil
Overall Rating: 4.5 of 5
"I really like the texture of this eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and doesn't feel like your eyelids are being stretched while you put it on. It won't last all day long, so you'll need to reapply it,"...(read full reviews)
Cream Shaper For Eyes
Overall Rating: 4.484 of 5
"I love the consistency of this eyeliner...it actually lives up to its name - creamy. I have this in chocolate and it's perfect for that smoky brown look for your lower lash line and/or water line."...(read full reviews)
Liquid Liner
Overall Rating: 4.484 of 5
"Long lasting and easy application, makes for the perfect cat eye ;)"...(read full reviews)
  1-20 of 122   More Eyeliner products