Sephora Ratings and Reviews
 
The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection
This product is no longer available. Continue shopping at Sephora .

CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

What it is:An exotic collection of five shimmering, mini eye pencils housed in a sleek, cigarette-style case.What it does: Line the eyes with shimmering, festive color for a holiday look that brings the allure of the East to your eyes. This collection of five, exotic mini-eye pencils-housed in a sleek, cigarette-style case-is the perfect stocking stuffer.The pencil's velvety texture ensures a smooth application of rich, intense color for eyes that pop all night long.This set contains:- Exotic Eggplant- Sparkling Green Tea- Midnight Blue- Tarnished Silver- Burnished OliveWhat else you need to know:Each petite pencil is adorned with vibrant, Eastern-inspired deco.

Average Rating: 3.58 of 5 3.6 out of 5

Questions & Answers: 2 Questions |  2 Answers

Reviews for CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Sort by
lorilynnm24
location Minneapolis, MN
Eye Color Hazel
Skin Tone Light
Age 18-24
Overall Rating 2 of 5 (2 out of 5 )
Not Great - 01.21.10
Beautiful colors and a great size for your purse but they do not go on very easily and they go on very lightly, almost making the color not show up. Considering I paid $18 for the set, it really wasn't worth it...
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

2CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Annalpnrn
location Crystal Falls, MI
Eye Color Brown
Skin Tone Medium
Age 35-44
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
Easy on - 01.20.10
Quick Take: good value

These eyeliners work great. They go on smoothly and allow you ease up on pull your lids to prevent damage to thin skinned eye area. the case is convienient for travel and all the colors allow you to play artist with your eyes.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

3CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

PattyD719
location Weslaco, TX
Eye Color Brown
Skin Tone Light
Age 25-34
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
- 01.19.10
Quick Take: good value

I LOVE LOVE LOVE each and every one of these pencils! I have brown eyes and each shade seems to compliment and enhance my eye color. I was afraid they were going to be ridiculously glittery, but they have just a bit of glitter in them. More of a shimmer really. Glide on very smoothly, no tugging at eyelid.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

4CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

sk8tergirl
location Chantilly, VA
Eye Color Blue
Skin Tone Medium
Age 45-54
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
Love it! - 01.18.10
Quick Take: good value

I love these pencills, what a great buy and the colors are smashing! As they were on sale it was really a bargain.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

5CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Jenroo
location Palmetto, Florida
Eye Color Blue
Skin Tone Light
Age 35-44
Overall Rating 4 of 5 (4 out of 5 )
Just bold enough - 01.18.10
Quick Take: good value

I was really looking forward to the colors. And I was NOT disappointed. Just enough color to make your eyes pop without going over board!
I have other colors for that! The plum color is divine!
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

6CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Deedster
location Houston, Texas
Eye Color Brown
Skin Tone Olive
Age 13-17
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
Great Product - 01.18.10
Quick Take: good value, good colors, easy to apply, not too much

The colors are all really nice, on first use they didn't come on so well, but afterwards they were easy to put on. The blue is the darkest color, all the others are more discreet. They all look really nice, without looking too unnatural. The olive green looks darker on the bottom lashes once you apply it and looks great with olive skin.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

7CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Dreamyone
location Chapel Hill, NC
Eye Color Brown
Skin Tone Light
Age 45-54
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
BEST EYE PENCIL VALUE EVER 5 PENCILS FOR $9 TOTAL - 01.16.10
Quick Take: great value, great product, colors i use all year round, stock up while still available, i love these - you will too

I was given this set along with a couple of Cargo Holiday Palettes (which I love and are on sale at half price - check them out). I really like the colors in this set, and they work really well with the Cargo Palettes (Runway and others). I really like the brown and the blue and the green, since I have brown eyes. The plum (eggplant) ends up giving my eyes a somewhat red look, so I gave that one away.(That's not a fault of the pencil - I find that with anything with reddish tones. I just can't report on that color). The colors last a long time. It was a great value for the money before it went on sale, and now, for $9 for five pencils, you won't be able to find a better deal anywhere. I sometimes use a primer and sometimes not. This pencil glides on easily with a primer. The shades can be used as liners, and also as shadows. The colors are intense and well pigmented. I sometimes put a very thin line of green above my normal brown eye liner. I like that effect.

I reviewed this previously but wanted to bring this to your attention because of the sale which makes this a phenomenal value. You're only paying $1.80 per shade, and you're getting a great product for the money. You can't find exceptional pencils like this anywhere else for that amount of money. Frankly, these pencils are well worth quite a bit more.

Since I started using these pencils, I've come to enjoy them even better than originally. One pencil was initially dryer than the others, but once the tip was used, it's been perfect. It might have been drier because of how it was stored in the warehouse - I don't believe it was a manufacturing issue.

Many of the Cargo collections are on sale now, or are available at reasonable costs. They're all exceptional values. You should pick up this set while it's still available, and also check out the other coordinating Cargo collections. Buy them before they sell out because all the collections, including this set can be used all year round. This set of pencils will take you from day to evening with ease. You really won't need any other pencils. You'll love them all.
0 of 14 people found this review helpful.
0 of 14 people found this review helpful.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

8CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

GrandmaSheila
location Rancho Santa Margarita CA
Eye Color Hazel
Skin Tone Light
Age 45-54
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
Excellent product & service - 01.13.10
Quick Take: good value

I love the product I ordered and the delivery service was great.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

9CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

MimiNJ
location New Brunswick, NJ
Eye Color Hazel
Skin Tone Medium
Age 35-44
Overall Rating 4 of 5 (4 out of 5 )
Gorgeous color, long-lasting - 01.13.10
Quick Take: good value

I ordered these eyeliners as the description was extremely appealing as well as the price. The colors of the pencils are so much better in person-very vivid colors that go onto the eyes with the full intensity. The liner does last a long time with minimal fading or movement-I find that the liners stay on longer with a eye primer. The downfall is that the casing when you sharpen the pencils, the wood breaks into small pieces that makes it hard to sharpen the pencils to a decent point and the hardness of the liner doesn't always allow for smooth gliding of application.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

10CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

glossgirl38
location toronto ontario
Eye Color Hazel
Skin Tone Light
Age 35-44
Overall Rating 1 of 5 (1 out of 5 )
hated these!! - 01.12.10
looked great when i tried the colours on my hand but very hard to use on my eyes and not great pigment. returned it as quickly as i could.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

11CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

fhbdfdg

Overall Rating 3 of 5 (3 out of 5 )
- 01.12.10
Quick Take: so-so

i have olive skin and these colors look good on it. they are a bit harder than the average pencil, which makes them good for thinner lines. they are surprisingly small, so i don't think i would pay for them again, but they are good for experimenting with colors i suppose.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

12CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

IVIa

Overall Rating 4 of 5 (4 out of 5 )
- 01.11.10
Quick Take: good value

for the price and the quality of eye liner is worht it....
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

13CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Pensfanatic
location Pittsburgh, PA
Eye Color Green
Skin Tone Olive
Age 25-34
Overall Rating 3 of 5 (3 out of 5 )
ok- its eyeliner- no thrills - 01.11.10
Thought the colors would be more bold- fairly muted- but good for work/everyday use
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

14CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

EmsB
location Cape Cod, MA
Eye Color Hazel
Skin Tone Fair
Age 18-24
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
Great - 01.10.10
Quick Take: good value

Love this product. I never finish a whole stick of eyeliner before it goes bad. Not only are these the perfect size but I love that I get so many colors. Always wanted to be one of those ladies who wore different colors but thought it silly to spend all the money when I would never use it all. Well now I feel like I have it all.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

15CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Climberextreme
location Dawson Creek, British Columbia
Eye Color Green
Skin Tone Medium
Age 25-34
Overall Rating 3 of 5 (3 out of 5 )
Great colors, poor application - 01.08.10
Quick Take: good value, colorful

The colors of these pencils are great and are good for adding some extra color. The only problem is they can be a little hard to apply to the eye. Besides color they don't offer too much over the typical eyeliner pencils.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

16CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

lizzybooboo

Overall Rating 4 of 5 (4 out of 5 )
Fun Stuff - 01.07.10
Quick Take: good value

These eyeliners are a lot of fun to play with. They have little flecks of glitter that give them an irridesant shine. Definately worth the price.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

17CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Sagwa
location Calgary, Alberta
Eye Color Brown
Skin Tone Medium
Age 13-17
Overall Rating 4 of 5 (4 out of 5 )
Great gift - 01.06.10
I gave this to a friend and she adored these eyeliners. I saw that they were very vibrant and when I tried a sample myself, the color glided on effortlessly!
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

18CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

GirlySue8168
location Taunton, MA
Eye Color Hazel
Skin Tone Fair
Age 25-34
Overall Rating 1 of 5 (1 out of 5 )
Hardly Intense Color - 01.06.10
Quick Take: dissapointing, prettily packaged

I was so excited to try smouldering Indian inspired eyes! HARDLY, and I do mean hard, these dry little pencils merely suggested their alluring colors after repeated application. I was expecting kohl type texture in deep jewel tones. I got chalky pencil reminders of what could have been.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

19CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Dreamyone
location Chapel Hill, NC
Eye Color Brown
Skin Tone Light
Age 45-54
Overall Rating 4 of 5 (4 out of 5 )
COLORS ARE GOOD, BUT PENCILS OCCASIONALLY PULL - 01.05.10
Quick Take: good value, a little dry, the colors are great, nice presentation case

I was given this set along with a couple of Cargo Holiday Palettes (which I love). I really like the colors in this set, and they work really well with the Cargo Palettes (Runway and others). I really like the brown and the blue and the green, since I have brown eyes. The plum (eggplant) ends up giving my eyes a somewhat red look, so I'm giving that one away. The colors last a long time, and it's a good value for the money. I sometimes use a primer and sometimes not, no matther what the brand of eye liner. I've found that this eye pencil collection sometimes pulls without primer. I've also noticed that one of the pencils seems a lot dryer than the others, which may account for some of the issues I have with it.

The shades can be used as liners, and also as shadows. The colors are intense and well pigmented. I sometimes put a very thin line of green above my normal brown eye liner. I like that effect.

I'm giving this four stars because I do prefer those from Urban Decay and Sephora, both of which have really great kits out right now. Those two brands have performed consistently smoother in application although I really like the Cargo colors, too. Since all of the collections are on sale now, or are available at reasonable costs, they're all good values. You should pick the set with the colors you will most likely use the most.
6 of 26 people found this review helpful.
6 of 26 people found this review helpful.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs

20CARGO The Eastern Eye Pencil Collection

Fara
location New York, NY
Eye Color Brown
Skin Tone Deep
Age 25-34
Overall Rating 5 of 5 (5 out of 5 )
Amazing! - 01.04.10
Quick Take: good value

The best colors in this are the dark green, the navy and the purple. They glide on pretty smoothly (I use an eye brightner as a base) and last forever. I've been lining my eyes with the usual brown, then running these bright, fun colors on top of the brown line for some color pop that's different from eyeshadow. A subtle, shimmery neutral shadow tops it out for a fun play on color that doesn't have an overrun 80's color look.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Share with friends MySpace Facebook Digg DelIcioUs