Summary of Customer Ratings & Reviews

Overall Rating

(4.5 out of 5 )

(4.5 out of 5)

What it's great for

great value (2)
all are matte (1)
dark colors (1)
good value (1)
pretty colors (1)
smooth (1)

Product Reviews

vinaigrette

location Chicago, Illinois

Eye Color Brown

Skin Tone Medium

Age 13-17

Overall Rating

(4 out of 5 )

Wowzers - 11.21.09

Quick Take: great value, smooth, pretty colors

Nice set. Cute packaging. Great value. Colors are very wearable. Nice texture. Only flaw I can think of is it comes off easily. Remember to exfoliate lips before applying. PS: 2 of the shades (Lala Land and Finders Keepers) are very similar in shade. Sugar Rush has more of a sparkle/tint to it. Others are more matte.

Share with friends

mdjone

location Tennessee

Eye Color Brown

Age 18-24

Overall Rating

(5 out of 5 )

must have - 11.21.09

3 for the price of one. and the colors are all alot more wearable than they may appear. i wish they would make more of these and do it with the silky finish lipsticks as well. these lipsticks are matte but theyre not drying at all and the colors are opaque but u can build them to as light or dark as u want.

Share with friends

beu2fool

location Palm Beach, FL

Eye Color Green

Skin Tone Medium

Age 25-34

Overall Rating

(3 out of 5 )

not for me - 11.18.09

I need to start off by saying that I love benefit lipstick. These colors just didn't work out too well for me. It is a great value, that's for sure. The colors were just too harsh for me to wear. I should have gone into the store and tested them individually, first.

2 of 2 people found this review helpful.

Share with friends

kemcl

location Purchase, NY

Eye Color Green

Skin Tone Fair

Age 18-24

Overall Rating

(5 out of 5 )

Amazing Deal - 11.16.09

Quick Take: great value

This set is 3 full-size, full-finish lip colors for the price of one, terrific deal! I'm am just over the moon that I was able to snag this set. The three colors are all very flattering on me, the is a light mauve color, a deep berry purple, and a a nice neutral red/brown color. Only the Sly, the red/brown, is one of my favorite lipsticks period, it's universally flattering and bold all at once! I would really recommend this set if you are a fan of Benefit's full-finish lipsticks.

Share with friends

stealmysunshine

location Left my heart in San Francisco.

Eye Color Brown

Skin Tone Light

Age 18-24

Overall Rating

(5 out of 5 )

- 11.13.09

Quick Take: good value, dark colors, all are matte

I think this is a really good value because the lipsticks are all full sized and would have cost $18 each if purchased separately. So this is a really amazing deal. The only bad thing about this is that you don't get to choose which colors you want. This set contains mostly deep berry colors. I liked all of them because even thought the colors are deep matte colors they still look beautiful on. I think this set is only good if you like dark lip color. None of them are "light" or sheer.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.

Share with friends

23skidoo

location New England

Eye Color Gray

Skin Tone Light

Age 25-34

Overall Rating

(5 out of 5 )

Hats off to Benefit! - 11.10.09

I was already a fan of Benefit Cosmetics (I wear BADgal mascara everyday and like the silky-finish lipsticks I've purchased). This is a great value--three for the price of one--and a great color selection. Overall I think these shades will flatter cool skin tones best since two of the shades have a purple rather than red base.

"Do Tell" is more purple than it looked online, and is probably my favorite. There's nothing "Barney" about it--it's a very flattering shade of orchid and suitable for day or evening. Plus, it coordinates perfectly with BADgal Plum.

"On the Sly" is the most universally flattering and a safe color--kind of a terracotta/mauve. Very neutral and good to have in your makeup bag.

"No Competition" is a deeper version of "Do Tell", but not at all dark or vampy.

The formula is great; glides on evenly with opaque coverage and is pretty moisturizing. This is a GREAT set. Benefit, if you're listening (er, reading) please make a similar set for your silky-finish line. I'd buy it in a heartbeat!

5 of 5 people found this review helpful.

Share with friends