Beckel
location
Columbus, OH
Eye Color
Green
Skin Tone
Fair
Age
35-44
|
 |
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
- 11.22.09
Quick Take: long wearing, waterproof, smudgable
I don't usually wear eye liner, but this eye liner is so easy to use and really adds a lot of umph to your eyes. I get tons of compliments whenever I wear it.
|
|
2MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
CJ27
location
Miami, FL
Eye Color
Brown
Age
18-24
|
|
Overall Rating
(4
out of 5
)
- 11.21.09
Quick Take: long wearing
Very smooth and highly pigmented!
|
|
3MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
light0122
location
north salem, NY
Eye Color
Green
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
45-54
|
|
Overall Rating
(1
out of 5
)
Not what was promised
- 11.21.09
Quick Take: d. not of the above
I asked the Sephora reps for an eyeliner that would stay put and be bright. I bought the gold and purple. Neither are true to their colors and did not stay in placed as promised. I would have returned them but kept trying to see if it would be better.
|
|
4MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
PerfumeNut
location
Emporia, KS
Eye Color
Hazel
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
over 54
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
Finally! A Great Eyeliner
- 11.21.09
Quick Take: long wearing
I love this liner because it goes on smoothly and doesn't smear and smudge all over your eyes. I'm glad I found it!
|
|
5MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Katee56
location
Milwaukee, WI
Eye Color
Blue
Skin Tone
Light
Age
45-54
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
Good Eyeliner
- 11.21.09
Quick Take: long wearing, waterproof, smudgable
This eyeliner lasts. Unlike the cheap stuff we buy at the local stores....... IT ACTUALLY LAST ALL DAY... sometime I do re-apply after the work day is over ..... but there is still color........
|
|
6MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
magdalenas
location
Toledo, Ohio
Eye Color
Brown
Skin Tone
Olive
Age
25-34
|
|
Overall Rating
(4
out of 5
)
does not smudge!
- 11.20.09
Quick Take: long wearing, smudgable
I have problems with eyelinears smudging under my eye, this is the only one I have ever found that does not smudge on me. Love it, just think it is a little pricey.
|
|
7MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
|
|
|
Overall Rating
(4
out of 5
)
- 11.20.09
Quick Take: long wearing, waterproof
Last pretty much all day. A lot better than sephora brand eyeliner. Overall Good buy.
|
|
8MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Chox
location
Hesperia CA
Eye Color
Brown
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
45-54
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
excellent
- 11.20.09
Quick Take: waterproof
I love it! it stays on all day without retouching
|
|
9MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Jessi116
location
Fort Lauderdale, FL
Eye Color
Hazel
Skin Tone
Light
Age
35-44
|
|
Overall Rating
(4
out of 5
)
Good Liner
- 11.20.09
Quick Take: long wearing, smudgable
I purchased the purple 11L. The color is beautiful, especially after I use it along with brown eye shadow. It lasts and it is good but it needs to be sharpened and that is not very convenient. I really liked the Channel waterproof eyeliner but the purple one has been discontinued. I would definitely buy again.
|
|
10MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
JennerTX
location
Austin, TX
Eye Color
Blue
Skin Tone
Light
Age
35-44
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
Perfect liner
- 11.20.09
Quick Take: long wearing, smudgable
I have several Make up forever liners and they are consistently my favorites! They apply easily and blend easily but don't really smudge. They stay on all day but with my favorite Josie Maran wipes, come right off.
|
|
11MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Aileys
location
Hoquiam, WA
Eye Color
Hazel
Skin Tone
Light
Age
18-24
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
My new favorite eye liner!
- 11.20.09
Quick Take: long wearing, smudgable
I'm very happy with my purchase. I have found my new favorite eye liner. This is a great every day eye liner. It doesn't smudge, goes on smoothly and doesn't need to be set. Just put it on and go! I put it on around 7am every morning and it stays on throughout the whole day, even after I workout at 6pm. I suggest this fully and I'm thankful I don't have to keep looking for the perfect liner, cuz I've found it! Phew! :)
|
|
12MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Dink03
location
Alaska
Eye Color
Hazel
Skin Tone
Light
Age
18-24
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
EASY!!!!
- 11.19.09
Quick Take: long wearing, waterproof, smudgable, glides on!
This is the easiest eye liner I have ever used, it goes on smooth and quick! Freakin Awesome!!
|
|
13MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
babyscoops
location
albuquerque, nm
Eye Color
Blue
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
35-44
|
|
Overall Rating
(2
out of 5
)
aqua eyes 3L
- 11.19.09
Quick Take: smudgable
Loved the color, however after 2 hours it did not stand up for me - as far as waterproof goes.
|
|
14MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Vic56
location
Havertown Pa.
Eye Color
Green
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
45-54
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
staying power
- 11.19.09
Quick Take: waterproof
Easy on ,( even crepey eyelids) great colors,stays put
|
|
15MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
SephoraRox
location
MA
Eye Color
Brown
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
18-24
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
Review for 11L and 12L
- 11.18.09
Quick Take: long wearing, waterproof
These are my first Aqua Eyes eyeliners and I love them! I usually use UD's 24/7 pencils, but these are just as good. The color of these are rich and do not fade away. They last throughout the day and are easy to apply. I want to get more!
|
|
16MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
CoastToCoast
location
Beverly Hills, CA
Eye Color
Green
Skin Tone
Olive
|
|
Overall Rating
(3
out of 5
)
Pretty colour & nice consitancy
- 11.18.09
Quick Take: long wearing, smudgable
This product is a creamy eyebrow pencil and unlike Anastasia, it isn't cake like. It goes on smooth and lasts a few hours. It also blends weel. It's a great pencil if you can afford it. Very expensive for what it is.
Reviewer Images
(click to zoom)
|
|
17MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
jobob55
location
Clayton, CA
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
45-54
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
Best of the Best
- 11.18.09
Quick Take: long wearing, waterproof, smudgable
This is the best liner pencil. It wears very well and doesn't move all day long!
|
|
18MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
KATinLA
location
Los Angeles, CA
Eye Color
Brown
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
25-34
|
|
Overall Rating
(2
out of 5
)
disappointed
- 11.17.09
I bought this because i am always looking for a great black eyeliner that goes on easy but stays on. When i put it on, i was very hopefully. It goes on very creamy but precise. I looked in the mirror a couple hours later and it had flaked and smeared all under my eyes. I returned it. Sigh.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful.
|
|
19MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Busy
location
Sacramento
Eye Color
Brown
Skin Tone
Medium
Age
35-44
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
Great
- 11.17.09
Quick Take: long wearing, waterproof, smudgable
I can use it as ashadow or eyeliner and waterproof.
|
|
20MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes
Moua
location
San Francisco
Age
35-44
|
|
Overall Rating
(5
out of 5
)
- 11.16.09
I love the color, it last all day long.. perfect
0 of 1 people found this review helpful.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful.
|
|
Print this page
