Sephora Ratings and Reviews
Body(1,371)
Eyes(306,087)
Brows(19,397)
Concealer(21,719)
Eye Makeup Remover(7,977)
Eye Sets & Palettes(35,242)
Eyeliner(78,946)
Eyeshadow(28,919)
Eyeshadow Base & Primer(19,724)
False Eyelashes(3,558)
Lash Enhancers(6,531)
Mascara(84,074)
Face(269,861)
Lips(125,431)
Makeup Brushes & Applicators(1,286)
Nails(37,855)
Palettes & Value Sets(10,507)
Shop Now At Sephora
Shop Eyeliner or
Choose a Category
Most Popular Products
Product Reviews
SEPHORA COLLECTION Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
What it is:An all-in-one eyeliner trio to line and define eyes for a dramatic look that lasts. What it does:Deep, true color and a long-lasting formula combine in this complete eyeliner package you’ll adore all-day long. The portable cream, cake, and brush applicator travel easy and promise endless, precise looks. The cream formula smudges to create glamorous smoky eyes, while the cake eyeliner draws on to match your style: soft for daytime or painted thick for dramatic evenings. Both the cream and cake liner are formulated with a new generation of black iron oxide for super intense black pigment with a water-proof finish. What it is formulated WITHOUT:- Parabens- Sulfates - Phthalates
Average Rating:
22 reviews
5 stars
7
4 stars
6
3 stars
2
2 stars
3
1 star
4
Sort by
reviews for SEPHORA COLLECTION Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Review 1 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Wanted to love it
-05.16.13
Wanted to love it, but I hate hate hate this product. Worse eye liner I've used every. The gel is so hard you can't really get the product on a brush, the powder doesn't apply well either. Returned
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 2 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Cheychey10
Dislike the brush applicator
-05.12.13
The brush is harsh and stiff. I bought it for a wedding I was in and first used it on another bridesmaid who said the same thing. You have to pack a lot of the brush for it to come off, then little flakes fall under your eye. It doesn't truly lock into place well.
On the other hand, if you have an eyeliner brush of your own it works better. It has pretty good pigmentation, but still have trouble with specks falling on my face. So far, it's still creamy not dry. Has the black shadow to set, blend, etc. Good price for what you get, but still considering returning.
On the other hand, if you have an eyeliner brush of your own it works better. It has pretty good pigmentation, but still have trouble with specks falling on my face. So far, it's still creamy not dry. Has the black shadow to set, blend, etc. Good price for what you get, but still considering returning.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 3 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Not a fan
-04.28.13
Quick Take: smudgable
I was thrilled to try this product as I use both liquid and powder for liner today. Unfortunately, a few things make it not worth buying. First, the brush never truly "sticks" in the full position so it's always sliding back and forth while trying to apply. Second, the brush is too wide for applying to the upper lid. I'm used to a clean line from liquid liner and this doesn't cut it. It is useful for a smudged/smokey eye look, though, and that's what I'll be using it for but would not purchase again.
+1point
1out of 1found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 4 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
treblemaker72
love it but.......
-04.26.13
Its very dry. I love that it lasts and doesn't smear. It's very dry to out on though. Wish it was a little more smooth
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 5 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Review 6 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Review 7 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
LynnsaySan
Does work
-04.07.13
I use the brush more than anything the brush is surprisingly great. I use it for brows. The powder in it works more so when it's wet. Doesn't work well dry. The cream included works well but doesn't stay well. I don't like my makeup to fade flake or wear off. The cream liner seems to wear off a bit but is good together with the brush and powder as a to go thing.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 8 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Staying Power!!!
-04.06.13
Quick Take: waterproof, long wearing
I saw this recently and I was really pleased with the outcome. I am a runner and I exercise in all weather, especially in rain. I've looked around for something that will give me a good, dramatic cat eye and won't run. And I've found it. I don't recommend using the brush for close lining, but the eye liners are great.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 9 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
bribe
-04.06.13
I love this my eyes look amazing
+1point
1out of 1found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 10 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Review 11 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
I really wanted to like this but...
-03.31.13
Quick Take: horrible
This product was horrible. The gel was not moist, so the gel very shortly clumped on the collapsible brush. The brush kept collapsing as attempted application. I had to clean the applicator off after every use.
+1point
1out of 1found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 12 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Synndee
-03.24.13
Love the staying powder. Love the texture. I like the brush but what I dnt like is that when I'm putting on my eyeliner the brush moves in if only I could lock it in place or something. I would buy this again once I'm done with it.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 13 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Long lasting
-03.24.13
Quick Take: waterproof, long wearing
It is thick and solid to work with but it is long lasting. You have to use it as directed for great results. Cream Eyeliner:
-Smudge along the lash line to create a glamorous smoky eye.
-Pull out brush and apply along the lash line.
-Clean brush after use to prevent stiffness due to waterproof formula.
-Close tightly after use.
-Smudge along the lash line to create a glamorous smoky eye.
-Pull out brush and apply along the lash line.
-Clean brush after use to prevent stiffness due to waterproof formula.
-Close tightly after use.
Cake Eyeliner:
-Use dry over the cream eyeliner to quickly set or get rid of any harsh lines.
-Remove with waterproof makeup remover.
-Always clean brush after use with Cream Eyeliner to prevent stiffness of brush.
-Pull out brush and dampen with clean water.
-Then dip brush into the Cake Eyeliner and work it into a thick paste and apply along the lash line.
-Use dry over the cream eyeliner to quickly set or get rid of any harsh lines.
-Remove with waterproof makeup remover.
-Always clean brush after use with Cream Eyeliner to prevent stiffness of brush.
-Pull out brush and dampen with clean water.
-Then dip brush into the Cake Eyeliner and work it into a thick paste and apply along the lash line.
+3points
3out of 3found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 14 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
rayon
Location:Lynwood, California
Skin Tone:Dark
Eye Color:Brown
Age:35-44
All n one
-03.18.13
Quick Take: waterproof
Truthfully I do not like it. It's really hard. Like its been sitting in the product supplies to long. Not using it.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 15 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
miacorn
Love it!
-03.18.13
Love it. Can't wait for them to make it in brown
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 16 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
A New Essential in my Makeup Kit!
-03.15.13
Quick Take: long lasting, easy to use, professional looking, good for a wide range of looks
As I've gotten older, it's been more difficult to find liquid liner that doesn't leak into the creases around my eyes and flake off. I have mostly used the cream liner by itself. It has awesome staying powder, even without the setting powder. It's easy to apply, stays all day, and is not the least bit messy. The brush does get a bit of buildup, but a little eye makeup remover will clean it right up.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 17 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
Not what I expected
-03.14.13
Quick Take: smudgable
This product is not what I expected. The gel is difficult to apply a smooth even line. It is also difficult to remove.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 18 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
not so great...
-03.13.13
the gel was weird and almost solidified. the liquid part, which needed water was fine. the brush wasnt exactly the best applicator. i am sure i can find a cheaper liner at a drug store that works much better for me....
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 19 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
All in all, not the best out there
-02.28.13
I'm a huge fan of dark eyeliners, especially to line the top eyelids. I was hoping that this would be something I could use for going out or even to work, but I'm not a huge fan of the texture or color. It's not as dark as I was hoping for, and it's not a true cream liner. That being said, for the price it's not terrible. It also has a black shadow included, which helps the liner set nicely. If you've never tried cream liner, then this may be a good starting point. Eyeliner experts, I wouldn't waste my time with it.
0points
0out of 0found this review helpful.
Share with friends
Review 20 for Pitch Black All-In-1 Waterproof Eye Liner
l3na5
Stays all day!
-02.18.13
This eyeliner is great. It stays on all day without smudging or flaking. It dries fast so you have to be able to apply quickly and a limited amount of time to smoke out or blend.
+1point
1out of 1found this review helpful.
Share with friends
